The first time you walk into Goodneighbor in Fallout 4, a man named Finn stops you at the gate and sells you insurance. Before you can decide what to do about it, a ghoul in a red frock coat and a tricorn hat strolls over, says Finn’s name in a friendly voice, and puts a knife into his chest several times.
Then he turns to you — a stranger who has been in town for forty seconds and has just watched a public killing — and says that Goodneighbor is of the people, for the people, you feel me? Everyone’s welcome.
That is his platform. It has two problems. The next line out of his mouth is “So long as you remember who’s in charge.” And the words are not his, and they are not the historical John Hancock’s either. They are Lincoln’s, and one third of the sentence has been removed. The third that is missing is “by the people.”
The face, the name and the clothes are all acquisitions. He was born John McDonough, and the coat came out of a smashed museum case.
Two sentences, with a body between them
A mayor who has just knifed a man in the street is welcoming you to stay. The scene is scripted and Finn always dies; all you can do is watch.
The order of the opening scene is the content of the opening scene.
Finn opens by selling protection: “You hand over everything you got in them pockets, or ‘accidents’ start happenin’ to ya.” Hancock cuts him off politely: “Someone steps through the gate the first time, they’re a guest. You lay off that extortion crap.” Finn does not back down: “You’re soft, Hancock. You keep letting outsiders walk all over us, one day there’ll be a new mayor.” Hancock walks over, draws a knife, and kills him.
One mechanical fact tends to get missed: this scene is scripted, and Finn always dies. The player gets three options — hear him out, threaten him, kill him first — and none of them save him. This is not an avoidable tragedy but a demonstration that happens no matter what you do, and the audience for it is you.
Then the sequence of the two lines. Hancock says Goodneighbor is “of the people, for the people, you feel me? Everyone’s welcome.” The player accepts that, and his reply is: “So long as you remember who’s in charge.” The direction on that line reads slow and threatening. The platform and its refutation are separated by one dialogue option.
And if you want to know who the demonstration was for, he says so upstairs. Inside the Old State House you can overhear him with his bodyguard, Fahrenheit:
Fahrenheit: “I could’ve handled Finn you know.”
Hancock: “Yeah, but it’s better if people know I can still get my hands dirty. Besides, it wasn’t personal. No need to torture the guy.”
Fahrenheit: “You always keep me from having fun.”
Three things at once. He had someone to do it for him. He did it himself anyway, in the street, in front of a newcomer. And his stated reason is not that Finn deserved it but that people should know. Killing Finn was not law enforcement; it was a maintenance operation on his own authority, performed on the whole town.
The motto is Lincoln’s, and a third of it is missing
Lincoln wrote three clauses and Hancock says two of them. The missing clause is the one his brother was holding.
“Of the people, for the people” sounds like something out of the founding generation, especially from a man who calls himself John Hancock and dresses in revolutionary clothes. It is not. The full sentence is Lincoln’s, delivered at Gettysburg on November 19, 1863: “that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” Three clauses. The historical John Hancock died in 1793, seventy years before the speech existed.
Hancock of Goodneighbor says two of the three. The one he leaves out is the middle one.
Whether that is deliberate, the game never says. It does say something adjacent: he knows the words are not his. On the moment he first used them, standing on the balcony:
“I had to say something. That first time I said ’em, they didn’t even feel like my words.”
They did not feel like his words because they were not.
The costume has the same kind of origin. He took enough chems to black out, and woke on the floor of the Old State House in front of a display case: “I might’ve still been high, but those clothes spoke to me, told me what I needed to do. I smashed the case, put them on, and started a new life. As Hancock.” He gave the name a title while he was at it — John Hancock, “first American hoodlum and defender of the People.”
A name out of a museum case, clothes out of the same case, a slogan borrowed from a different president. The only thing this man picked out for himself is the face, and the face has a worse story than any of it.
Goodneighbor really does run without the missing third
The brick building on the right is the Old State House: town hall, guard bunkhouse, the mayor’s residence, and the balcony he threw the last mayor from.
Dropping a clause could be carelessness. What makes it hard to read that way is that the town runs exactly like the shortened version.
Across all of Fallout 4, Goodneighbor never holds an election, a vote, a council, or any procedure for succession. Where his authority comes from is stated plainly: he and his militia killed the previous mayor’s enforcers, then took Vic himself and threw him off the Old State House balcony with a rope around his neck. A crowd gathered underneath, he felt he ought to say something, and that is where the slogan comes from. He calls it his inaugural address.
Nor is order kept by an institution. The Railroad’s internal write-up of the town:
“Mayor Hancock and his squeeze Fahrenheit are holed up here. The mayor is well liked, if a little cutthroat. He is guarded by the Neighborhood Watch; don’t confuse them with the less friendly Triggermen!”
Well liked, a little cutthroat, protected by an armed guard. That describes a monarch, not an elected official.
And Goodneighbor is genuinely a good place, which should not be blurred. The same document calls it “truly equal,” says “there is no bigotry, and even Ghouls are accepted,” and credits the town as instrumental to the Railroad’s operations. Daisy, a ghoul who was alive before the bombs, says it is one of the few places in the Commonwealth that takes ghouls at all.
The question is not whether the town is good. It is that it is good entirely because of who happens to be sitting on the second floor of the State House, and nothing guarantees the next occupant will be the same. Exactly one line in the entire game raises the subject of a change in power — Finn’s “one day there’ll be a new mayor” — and the man who said it was killed on the spot, by someone who later explained that it plays better if people see him do it.
His brother had the votes, and paid for them with ghouls
Hancock’s older brother. He did not steal it, seize it, or stage a coup. He put No Ghouls Allowed on the ballot and won the election.
Read Goodneighbor on its own and you might conclude Hancock’s arrangement is simply what the wasteland allows. But Fallout 4 supplies a control group, and the control group is his brother.
Hancock was born John McDonough. Mayor McDonough of Diamond City is his older brother; they grew up in a shack on the waterfront, in what Hancock calls a “pretty happy childhood.”
And his brother won an election. The campaign was called Mankind for McDonough, and the policy attached to it was strict “No Ghouls Allowed” politics. Hancock explains the arithmetic:
“There’d always been a pretty big gulf between the folks living in the stands and folks down on the field. McDonough ran on it because he thought enough of those Upper Stands assholes would vote for him. Guess he was right.”
After the inauguration speech, Diamond City started expelling its ghouls. Hancock describes it as “families with kids lining up to drag folks they called ‘neighbor’ out of their homes and throw ’em to the ruins.” He went to his brother’s office to beg him to stop. This passage is the one worth reading word for word:
“I remember storming into his office above the stands after the inauguration speech. He was just standing there, staring out the window, watching as the city turned on the Ghouls. He didn’t even look at me, just said: ‘I did it, John. It’s finally mine.’
Should have killed him right there, but I don’t think it would have changed anything. Instead I pleaded with him, begged him to call it off.
He said he couldn’t. He had nothing against the Ghouls. He was just carrying out the will of the people. And he couldn’t betray the voters. And then he smiled. […] He never smiled like that when we were kids. I didn’t even recognize him.”
He had nothing against the ghouls; he was carrying out the will of the people. That is “by the people.” Procedurally clean, legitimately sourced, counted one ballot at a time. What it counted out was an order to drag a category of people from their homes into the ruins.
One detail deserves pulling out: Hancock was not a ghoul yet. In his words, “I still wasn’t a Ghoul at this point, so I didn’t have to leave, but I couldn’t bring myself to stay in that cesspool after that.” The decree did not apply to him; he left anyway, and used the safe routes learned from years of sneaking off to Goodneighbor for chems to walk a few of the expelled families out. The second half of that memory is less quotable: they could not adjust to the Goodneighbor lifestyle, he brought them food for a couple of weeks, and then they disappeared.
So the ledger reads like this. One brother took power by ballot, one by rope. The one with the ballot drove the ghouls out of his city; the one with the rope took them into his. Hancock leaving “by the people” out of his motto does not read like ignorance. It reads like a man who has seen what by the people looks like.
It begins with a sentence: and we all just stood there
He did not arrive in Goodneighbor as the man in the coat. He arrived as a drifter, living under Vic — scum who “used us drifters like his own personal piggy bank,” with a goon squad let off the leash periodically to blow off steam on the population. “Folks with homes could lock their doors, but us drifters, we got it bad.” And then one night:
“There was one night, some drifter said something to them. They cracked him open like a can of Cram on the pavement. And we all just stood there. Did nothing.”
The direction on that line is disgusted with his own behavior. If the player tries to soften it, he refuses the offer: “I appreciate you trying, but there’s no need to sugarcoat it. It was spineless, the way I acted.”
He felt “like less than nothing,” got high, and blacked out completely. He woke on the floor of the State House, in front of the clothes. That order sets the character of everything after it: Hancock is not a decision. Hancock is something picked up off a floor after a blackout. His own account is that the clothes spoke to him and told him what to do. He does not claim he worked anything out.
He hanged a man from the balcony where the Declaration was first read
What he did after putting the clothes on is entirely lucid: went clean for a while, organized the drifters, talked the arms dealer KL-E-0 into loaning him hardware, took a crew into the ruins to train, so that the next time Vic’s men went on their tear they would be ready. That night in his own words:
“So the night of, we all got loaded, let Vic’s boys get good and hammered, and burst from the windows and rooftops where we’d been hiding. They never even saw it coming. We didn’t have to fire a shot. We didn’t have to. But we sure fucking did. It was a massacre.”
The direction marks the emphasis in the third sentence: the stress falls on have. This is not remorse that slipped out. It is how he tells the story, every time.
“Once we’d mopped up, we strolled right into Vic’s quarters in the State House, wrapped a rope around his neck, and threw him off the balcony.” The inaugural address comes after that.
Now consider what that balcony is. The Old State House is the oldest public building in Boston, built in 1713, seat of the Massachusetts government before the Revolution — where, according to John Adams, “the child Independence was born.” The Boston Massacre took place directly outside its doors in 1770, and on July 18, 1776, Bostonians heard the Declaration of Independence for the first time, read aloud from that building’s balcony. In Fallout 4 it survived the Great War intact and now serves as Goodneighbor’s town hall, the Neighborhood Watch bunkhouse, and Hancock’s residence. The placard still stands outside, and the player can read it.
So: a man calling himself John Hancock hanged someone from the balcony where the Declaration of Independence was first read aloud, then stood on the same balcony and gave an inaugural address in Lincoln’s words — and the word he uses for that night is “a massacre,” the same word on the placard by the door.
To be clear: the game never has a character point any of this out. The placard is real, the history is real, his lines are quoted exactly — but putting them side by side is mine, and is claimed as such at the end of this article.
Even the face was chosen: he knew what the drug would do
Hancock did not become a ghoul by exposure. He took something, and knew in advance what it was for. He has two versions of the story, and the difference between them is the whole man. For people he does not know well: “Any chems I could find, the more exotic, the better. Finally found this experimental radiation drug. Only one of its kind left, and only one hit. Oh man, the high was so worth it. Yeah, I’m living with the side effects, but hey, what’s not to love about immortality?”
Once his affinity is high enough, the same event comes out like this:
“Well, I mean, I didn’t always look this good. The drug that did this to me, that made me a Ghoul, I knew what it was going to do. I just couldn’t stand looking at the bastard I saw in the mirror anymore. The coward who’d let all those Ghouls from Diamond City die. Who was too scared to protect his fellow drifters from Vic and his boys. If I took it, I’d never have to look at him again. I could put that all behind me. I’d be free. Didn’t seem like a choice at all.”
Choosing ghoulification is not unique in Fallout — Fallout 76 eventually let players walk into a silo and do it to themselves. But that is a choice about how to keep living. Hancock is the only case I have found where it was used as a sentence someone passed on himself: not to get stronger, not to last longer, but to stop having to look at a particular face. Face, name, clothes, motto — all four replaced. The opposite extreme is Harold, who never chose his face at all, and who wants the whole thing to stop at the exact moment a settlement kneels down and calls him a god. The last line of that conversation is his own verdict on the method:
“Turns out it was just me running from somethin’ else in my life.”
The pardon he gives his brother does not survive the text
Finish the quest In Sheep’s Clothing and you learn that Mayor McDonough is an Institute synth. Tell Hancock, and he throws out everything he has believed for a decade: the Institute really did replace his brother, and he hated him all those years for the wrong reason. Secondhand accounts follow that line almost without exception, and most writing about these brothers lands on some version of “it wasn’t really his fault.”
The text does not support the reconciliation. The replacement is dated in-game to some point after he was elected, while the expulsions begin immediately after the inauguration speech. More importantly, Mankind for McDonough was campaign material — the thing he used to win, before there was anything to replace. A synth swap cannot account for an anti-ghoul platform run during the election, and it cannot account for “he thought enough of those Upper Stands assholes would vote for him.”
There is corroboration on the other side too. The synth McDonough, talking privately later, says: “I ran on a campaign of strict ‘No Ghouls Allowed’ politics. When you build up a scapegoat, you need them to remain distant and scary.” Whoever is saying that knows exactly what he is doing and why it works.
Two readings remain open and the game closes neither: either Hancock is right and his brother stopped being his brother at some point, or Hancock has found an explanation he can live with and the man who signed the expulsion order was his actual brother. This article does not rule on it.
But one thing can be said. What Hancock does, over and over, is issue himself a replacement version he can survive. A new face, a new name, new clothes, a motto that belongs to someone else. In the end he issues one for his brother too. And even he cannot quite commit to that one, which is why the words he uses are “I hated him for the wrong reason” rather than “he didn’t do it.”
Three things people get wrong
“Hancock was turned into a ghoul by radiation exposure.” No. He took an experimental radiation drug, the last dose of its kind, and states outright that he knew what it would do. That is not how the overwhelming majority of wasteland ghouls are made, and it is what most separates him from every other named ghoul. The origin of ghouls generally is a messier argument, covered in the article on ghouls.
“‘Of the people, for the people’ is a John Hancock quote.” No. The full sentence is Lincoln’s, from the Gettysburg Address of 1863, and it has three clauses, not two. The historical John Hancock died in 1793. The version in the game is missing the middle clause, and the character himself has said those words “didn’t even feel like my words.”
“His brother was a synth, so the ghoul expulsion wasn’t really him.” The timing does not work. The replacement is placed after the election, while the anti-ghoul platform was the campaign itself and the expulsions followed the inauguration speech. Hancock’s doubt is a line of his dialogue, not a conclusion the game reaches.
Frequently asked questions
How did Hancock become a ghoul? He did it to himself with a drug. In his early years in Goodneighbor he took anything he could find, and eventually found an experimental radiation drug with a single dose left. He knew it would ghoulify him and took it anyway, because he could not stand the man in the mirror who had done nothing while Diamond City turned on its ghouls. For how ghouls are made in general, and where the widely repeated “radiation plus FEV” line comes from, see the full breakdown on ghouls.
How is Hancock related to Mayor McDonough of Diamond City? They are brothers, and Hancock is the younger one. His birth name is John McDonough and they grew up together in a shack on the Diamond City waterfront. The older brother won the mayoralty on a No Ghouls Allowed platform and expelled the city’s ghouls; the younger one left, and later became mayor of Goodneighbor.
Who was the real John Hancock, and what is the connection? The man with the largest signature on the Declaration of Independence and the first governor of Massachusetts, who died in 1793. The character is not related to him. He blacked out on chems, woke in the Old State House in front of the display case holding the historical Hancock’s clothes, smashed it, put them on, and took the name — adding a title of his own: “first American hoodlum and defender of the People.”
What does he give you as a companion? Maxing his affinity unlocks Isodoped: the higher your radiation, the faster your critical meter fills. The perk is the man in miniature — he turned radiation from an injury into an asset, exactly as he turned the worst night of his life into a founding myth. He also hands you chems from time to time.
How this article sources its claims
Tier one: text inside the works. Nearly everything here sits at this tier — Hancock’s complete dialogue in Fallout 4 including his affinity conversations, Mayor McDonough’s dialogue, Finn’s dialogue and the scripted entrance scene, the loading-screen text and placard for Goodneighbor and the Old State House, and the Railroad’s internal notes on the town.
Tier two: official statements and tie-in publications. Used twice, only as corroboration: the Fallout Shelter Online character description, which dates his ghoulification to 2282, and the product copy for Modiphius’ Fallout: Wasteland Warfare. Neither is text from the games, and where they conflict with the games the games win.
Tier three: early design notes (the Fallout Bible, 2002). Not used in this article. The Bible predates Fallout 4 by thirteen years. There is no Hancock in it and no Goodneighbor.
Tier four: my own inference. Three readings here are mine rather than the game’s. First, the missing “by the people” — the game never notes that the motto is short a clause and never mentions Lincoln. Second, setting the real history of the Old State House next to what Hancock does on the same balcony; the placard and the history are real, but the line between them is one I drew. Third, reading the brothers as ballot against rope — the game gives each account in full and never puts a character in a position to compare them.
Sources
In-game text and data. Fallout 4: Hancock’s dialogue, including the Goodneighbor entrance scenes and the affinity conversations covering Vic, the Diamond City expulsions, the experimental drug and the inaugural address; the overheard State House conversation with Fahrenheit; Mayor McDonough’s dialogue; Finn’s dialogue and the entrance script; loading-screen text for Goodneighbor and the Old State House; the Old State House placard; the Railroad’s notes on Goodneighbor; dialogue for In Sheep’s Clothing; the Isodoped companion perk.
Licensed material. Fallout Shelter Online character description; Modiphius, Fallout: Wasteland Warfare product copy.
Real-world history. Abraham Lincoln, the Gettysburg Address, November 19, 1863 (National Park Service, Lincoln Home). The United States National Park Service page for the Old State House records that Bostonians heard the Declaration of Independence for the first time on July 18, 1776, read from the balcony of the building, and that the Boston Massacre took place outside it in 1770. Both statements can be checked against that page directly.
0 Comments